By Jeff Halper
The people of Palestine have done it again, taking their own fate in their hands after being let down by their own “moderate” political leadership and, indeed, the entire international community in their struggle for freedom. Early this morning they simply blew up the wall separating Gaza from Egypt, breaking a siege imposed on them by an Arab government in collaboration with Israel.
We, the peoples of the world, should take great pride and encouragement in this quintessentially civil society refusal to accept subjugation, to abandon their fate to governments, including their own, for whom the lives of ordinary people are simply grist for their political charades – Annapolis and its subsequent “peace process” being but the last cynical expression. For the Palestinians represent far more than just themselves. Their refusal to submit to the dictates of governments, or to governments’ lack of interest in the well-being of people in general, reflects the desire of billions of oppressed people for identity, freedom, a decent life and actualization of their collective and individual rights and potentials. Most of the oppressed, the “wretched of the earth” as Franz Fanon called them a half-century ago, are too preoccupied with the daunting daily struggle for survival to organize and resist. Others do resist in a myriad of ways, but are most often repressed by their own political and economic “leaders,” disappearing anonymously from view. In a few cases they have managed to mount effective resistance to oppression, even to prevail – though the billions spent on “counterinsurgency” warfare by the US, Europe, Russia, Israel and many “developing” nations augur ill for peoples attempting to overthrow oppressive regimes.
In this the Palestinians stand at the forefront, in the front lines of peoples’ insistence everywhere that their rights, well-being and fundamental values as human beings be respected by governments. And they do so (and I write this as an Israeli with great sorrow and shame) against one of the world’s strongest and most ruthless military powers – a power that has dispossessed them from 85% of their land, which is trying to transform its occupation into a permanent regime of apartheid, which has spent decades impoverishing and disenfranchising them; the fourth largest nuclear power which nevertheless casts itself as the victim. Not only have the Palestinians experienced the dehumanization all oppressed and colonized peoples experience, not only have they been made into the embodiment of the rich and powerful’s greatest fear, evil “terrorists” who may tear down their privileged “civilization,” but they have been turned into guinea pigs. Israel is able to gain an edge in the counterinsurgency industry and win entree into the heart of the American military/hi tech complex by turning the Occupied Territories into a laboratory for the development of fiendish weaponry and tactics intended for use against people.And yet the Palestinian people – and in particular those who remain sumud, steadfast, in Palestine – continue not only to resist but to surprise and confound its would-be Israeli master at every turn. Despite unlimited control, a complete monopoly over the use of force, utter callousness and a vaunted Shin Beit, Israel’s military intelligence, Palestinians vote as they want, resist, carry on their daily lives with dignity – and blow huge holes in the walls and policies constructed in order to imprison and defeat them.
All this is not on the minds of those desperate people who surged into Egypt today. They may not have the “Big Picture.” Yet they deserve the respect and gratefulness of every person who cherishes a better world based on human rights and dignity, a world that is inclusive. As an Israeli Jew, I have been saddened and mortified that my own people, after all they have experienced, cannot see what they are doing to others. But on a larger scale, not as an Israeli Jew but as a human being, I take heart in the Palestinians’ active refusal to be ground under a global system that is producing unimaginable wealth and power for a few at the expense of the growing ranks of the wretched.I am not a Palestinian; I am not one of the oppressed. I only hope I can use my privilege in an effective way in order to redeem the gift the people of Gaza have given all of us: the realization that the people do have power and can prevail even in the face of overwhelming power. We may each express our responsibility towards the people of Gaza in whatever way most suits us, but as the privileged we must do something. We owe the Palestinians and the Palestinians writ large at least that.
(Jeff Halper is the Coordinator of the Israeli Committee Against House Demolitions – ICAHD).
11 Comments
Comments RSS TrackBack Identifier URI
Leave a comment



Stumble It!





It was not “moderate” leadership which let Palestinians down, it was Hamas. By continuing on its isolationist rejectionist policies, and continuing to perpetuate rocket attacks on Israel, Hamas has shown its strategy: Cause Israel to blockade, and open the door to Egypt.
In this way, Hamas’ direction lies in breaking all economic and logistic ties with Israel and creating new Egyptian ones. Here Hamas and Israel effectively agree. Let Egypt and not Israel be responsible for Gazans’ needs, as long as they will not recognize Israel.
But isn’t it the responsibility of the Israeli government because of their territorial control of the region? If you think about it, Israel’s control of the Gaza borders (both land and sea) and the borders of the West Bank show that Israel is the “owner” (for lack of a better word) of the region and is therefor responsible for the citizens of that region. This is in the same context of British and American colonialism. I mean are American Samoa and Puerto Rico gathering money and food from China or are they the responsibility of America?
I do agree however that making economic ties with Egypt will only strengthen the chances for an independant state.
Israel’s territorial control of the region? Did you not forget the unilateral withdrawal of 2005?
It was that withdrawal that allowed the Gazans to show their true colors: they elected a terrorist government that refused to disavow violence and live up to prior agreements.
Gaza is not only a colony in the sense that, being run by Hamas, it is a colony of Iran, just like south Lebanon, run by the other Iran proxy army, Hezbollah.
Iran is the true colonialist here, murdering any resident who voices a desire for peace with Israel, and like so many tyrannies before, using Palestinians as pawns. If they stood up to Iran, and al qaeda and recognized Israel, they’d have a potential future.
You are neglecting the facts. Israel maintains border control, collects taxes and provides services, you know the functions of a government. All the withdrawal signified was a removal of the military presence. Politically it is still recognized as Israeli territory. To simply blame all things on Iran shows a misunderstanding of the region. The “party of god” and hamas are two independent entities with radically different religious viewpoints. The only thing the two share in common is its opposition to Israel.
You miss some important facts:
1. The Israeli withdrawal from Gaza was much more than military, ‘though that would be significant enough. Some 5,000 civilian inhabitants left their homes in Gaza.
2. If you are calling it Israeli territory politically (which Israel does not), then you are saying Israel rightfully has sovereignty there. Then why can’t it act to protect its people from rockets and suicide bombers?
3. Opposition to Israel is not the only think that Hamas and Hezbollah have in common. They are both on Iran’s payroll. Iran arms and trains them both. And they act under the rule of Iran’s Supreme Leader. That’s why the Lebanon war broke out conveniently as the UN began an investigation into the role of Syria, another Iranian employee, in the assassination of Hariri, a moderate Lebanese official.
You would like Israel to be responsible for Gaza’s infrastructure, but not to stop the use of that infrastructure to murder Israeli civilians. You can’t have it both ways.
So 5000 people had to leave illegal settlements, where is your concern for the almost 4 millian palestinian refugees who left their homes in fear between 1947 and 1967? They were civilians, they simply wanted to live their lives in peace.
If Gaza is not Israeli territory why is it not deemed to be a sovereign nation by the UN or the US? Israel still has control, to claim otherwise is ridiculous. If they don’t want to be responsible they should declare Gaza as its own country.
Israel can protect it citizens, by making peace. If the occupation were to end I can easily state that the violence would decrease to the same levels as other nations.
Who cares is Iran supports these groups? Explain to me how Iran can arm and train groups like Hamas when Israel has border control. You would think they would prevent people from entering.
Hariri was probably killed by Syrian forces, but how many leaders have American and its puppet (israel) killed. Your morality, though no fault of your own, extends to only one side of this conflict.
Lastly I would like Israel to be responsible to its citizens, even the arab ones. The simple fear of democracy is what is keeping Israel from ending the conflict. They fear a democratic arab state and they fear the arab vote within their own nation.
“Israel can protect it citizens, by making peace.”
With Hamas, a group sworn to destroy Israel violently (and daily acting on that oath)? To Hamas, “occupation” means not only Gaza and the West Bank, but all of Israel. No country will sacrifice itself for peace. Israel is openly dedicated to a two state solution, but Hamas is sworn to oppose it. How do you make peace with one sworn to kill you?
I don’t know, ask the american indians.
This is not based on facts. It was not the “civil society” that tore the wall down but hamas itself (http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,325091,00.html)
(http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/947775.html)
And why is the world not protesting against Egypt that they have a wall that separates it from the Gaza strip?? When Israel has a wall somewhere it is outrageous, when Egypt has, it is not even commented!!
Israel is demonized when occupying Gaza, Israel is demonized when cutting off ties with Gaza. The international community demands from Israel to pull out of occupied territoroes (what it did concering Gaza!!!!) and at the time demands from Israel to feed the Gaza population. Nobody would demand from Egypt to feed the Gazans even though it is a neighbouring country like Israel. Or demand it from the richer than rich Arab Gulf countries.
No matter what Israel is doing, it is demonized anyway. This is called anti-semitism.
by the way, my father and his family had to flee from czechoslovakia. they fled to austria. they did not wait in a refugee camp until they would go back. they came to terms with the fact that they could not go back! they started a new life in austria. why don’t the palestinians integrate in the countries where they are at the moment like lebanon, jordan? you cannot wait for 40 years and only repeat “refugee, refugee”. You should demand from the countries where the Palestinians reside at the moment that these countries give them citizenship and possibilities.
Well guess what, some people stand up to injustice. Must be nice to be the spawn of cowards.